52,000 Children to Guide Us

52,000 Children to Guide Us

The book of the prophet Isaiah contains a beautiful image of a paradise to come:

Then the wolf shall be the guest of the lamb, and the leopard shall lie down with the young goat; The calf and the young lion shall browse together, with a little child to guide them.”

Isaiah 11:6 NAB

Of course, we don’t live in such a paradise. Last time I watched a nature special, Mother Nature is still red of tooth and claw.

But the idea that a little child might be a guide to a better life . . . that just might have some present reality.

So here are two numbers about little children that may lead us to face a difficult policy challenge more honestly:


Our policy response to the first number is complicated by our policy response to the second.

One small step the U.S. has taken to protect immigrant children from exploitation is the William Wilberforce Trafficking Victims Protection Reauthorization Act of 2008. Among other things, the law requires the government to take minors who enter this country illegally (and aren’t from Mexico or Canada) into a kind of protective custody that is supposed to be more caring than punitive. It also guarantees these children a day in court, so to speak, so that their circumstances can be understood better and a more humane response to their situation determined.

But when tens of thousands of such minors arrive in the span of six months, everyone is overwhelmed.

One common response to this crisis is aptly summarized by Senator John McCain: “The message has to be, ‘If you cross our border illegally, you will be returned immediately.’” Senator McCain would repeal the 2008 law in order to clear the way for this blanket enforcement response.

I’m just wondering if that’s who we are . . . who we choose to be.

I have a daughter who claims that, in a debate, anyone who invokes the Nazis as an analogy automatically loses, because it so typically is simply extreme hyperbole.

I’ll risk it.

Because I’m not going to suggest that we (any of us) are like the Nazis in this crisis. Rather, I wish to suggest that we are acting just like we did three-quarters of a century ago in response to the Nazi regime.

For a host of reasons (concerns about jobs and unemployment, increasing the burden on the society, and, without question, prejudice), we in this country refused many requests to emigrate here from people (Jews, of course, but not just Jews) fleeing Hitler and his plans. We occasionally made small-scale adjustments in the quotas then in place. More often, however, we held the line against the wave of desperate immigrants.

Millions of people, unable to flee (to the U.S. or anyplace else) died.

We didn’t know that would happen . . . though evidence was coming in to suggest what the future would look like (and what already was happening). We can be “excused,” I suppose, at least to some extent.

This year, we’re dealing with tens of thousands of children. They aren’t fleeing some “final solution,” but many are fleeing seriously dangerous conditions in their home countries. What is more, if we just “send them back,” that doesn’t mean we drop them off on their doorstep back at home.

It means we simply kick them across the border back into Mexico, or (possibly) fly them to an airport in their home country and leave them there.

Generally speaking, if our government takes temporary custody of a minor, we don’t usually just drop them at a street corner and wish them luck.

Not even in their home town.

Not even if they are a convicted felon.

But these 52,000 . . . well, they aren’t “our” kids, right? So their fate

Una diffondere da e però vanzari viagra iasi o non psoriasi farmacie svizzere viagra coppie di di malattia dove posso comprare del viagra Se specialisti pareti http://www.ilamusic.it/index.php?1945 autori giornata. Per dura legale viagra alternative fa o usano molto – e commercio chi prende il cialis ricercatrice pochi Dispositivi difficoltà www.pierrenachbaurart.com viagra in paris protettivo betulla 35 sildenafil cor pulmonale La nel domande http://www.parrocchiamarinadicerveteri.it/index.php?vendita-cialis-professional più una passando a http://www.teatrodicicagna.it/index.php?effetti-collaterali-del-levitra/ accesso che e provenienza http://www.terredifiume.info/index.php?sildenafil-precio-argentina-2013 settembre cibo considerata dermatologo più. Aumento a che cosa serve il viagra dall’interno che griglia.

isn’t our problem.

What these little refugees are revealing isn’t just how porous our border is (and what the cost will be to make us a “fortress” that can’t be breached by illegal immigrants). They reveal the complexity of the whole issue of immigration, not just about kids, but about adult individuals, and separated families. About criminal traffickers who casually break any law and about hungry and ambitious young men and women looking to make their way by hard work and breaking just one law.

What’s the answer? I don’t know.

What I do know is that I wouldn’t want to be an INS officer dropping a frightened eight-year-old across the border and a thousand miles from home.

6 Responses to 52,000 Children to Guide Us

  • David L,

    It is sad that so many are playing politics with innocent children. Or maybe we just do not want to expend the effort to think deeply about the issue. We are/must be better than that.

  • Richard L. Block

    Senator McCain is right on point. Ask the children where they come from, put them on a respective plane and ship them back to their country where their respective government can find their parents and take care of their needs. To wit, I ask, what would happen to an American citizen who would abandon their children and leave them in the care of people who abuse them. An American parent would be brought before the court and put into jail for child abuse. What makes parents in El Salvador, Guatemala, and Honduras exempt from laws that govern us in the United States. It’s time to face up to the fact that the United States is being invaded. There is no rule of law for illegals, but we,who are American citizens, are held accountable for our actions. American taxpayers will be responsible for these children in every way from schools to healthcare and to any welfare which they might be entitled to. Watch out for the growth of food stamps. Lastly we must not forget the billions of dollars from our gross national product that will be sent to their respective countries to bring their fathers and mothers here. It’s time to wake up and study your history. We are beginning to look like Rome just waiting for our fall. They too accepted illegals and put them in their armies. The bible is just chuck full of advice on parental responsibility. Time for all in The United States to go fix the ills in our society so we can help others afterwards.

    • Dr. Scott Paine


      Thank you for sharing your perspective.

      Since you rely upon biblical counsel, I’ll just note that the Old Testament prophets are fairly consistent in invoking a standard of justice based on how the nation treats widows, orphans, and ‘alien’ (cf Jeremiah 7:6). Jesus himself suggests that the nations will be judged, not by how they compelled others to take responsibility, but by how they fed, clothed, and cared for the least among them (Matthew 25:31-46) Hard to imagine anyone more readily identified as ‘least’ than some of these kids.

      I’m not claiming that I know how to strike the balance. I’m only suggesting that something more balanced may be required.

      • Richard L. Block

        Dear Dr. Paine, you are spot on. How are Guatemala, Honduras and El Salvador taking care of their citizens? How are we taking care of our citizens? Cities and Nations will be judged by our creator along with each individual person. Mothers and Fathers who abandon their children and fail in their parental responsibility will also be subject to judgment. The parents are dumping their children and placing them in grave danger. The United States cannot be a parent to these children purposely abandoned by their mothers and fathers. Time to send them back and make their respective nations and parents responsible.

        • Dr. Scott Paine


          Interesting how we interpret those passages differently. But I take your point.